Russia's War in Ukraine: Military and Intelligence Aspects Date: October 26, 2023 by NotebookLM
Summary
This document, produced by the Congressional Research Service, provides an overview of the military and intelligence aspects of Russia’s war in Ukraine. The report examines the events leading up to the invasion, including Russia's military buildup and the initial invasion itself. The report then covers the various phases of the conflict, including the initial Russian advances, the Ukrainian counteroffensives, and the ongoing attritional warfare. The report concludes with an assessment of the current situation and future outlook, addressing the challenges facing Russia's defense industrial base, and potential issues for the U.S. Congress.
Briefing Doc: Russia's War in Ukraine: Military and Intelligence Aspects
Date: October 26, 2023
Key Themes:
Miscalculations and Adaptation: Russia significantly misjudged Ukraine's capacity for resistance and the West's willingness to provide support. The initial invasion plan, relying on rapid decapitation and minimal civilian impact, failed spectacularly. However, Russia has adapted throughout the conflict, incorporating lessons learned into its tactics, equipment, and force structure.
Attrition Warfare: The conflict has largely devolved into a war of attrition, with both sides heavily reliant on artillery and long-range precision munitions. The ability to replenish personnel and equipment, particularly ammunition, has become a critical factor. Russia's defense industry is struggling to meet wartime demands, while Ukraine heavily relies on Western support.
The Counteroffensive and Future Trajectory: Ukraine's summer 2023 counteroffensive, aimed at liberating occupied territories, has made slow progress due to Russia's layered defenses and extensive minefields. While Ukraine has achieved tactical successes, the operational impact remains limited. The trajectory of the war hinges on which side can better sustain combat power and effectively manage attrition rates.
Most Important Ideas/Facts:
Pre-Invasion Buildup:
Russia assembled 150,000-190,000 personnel and 120 Battalion Tactical Groups (BTGs) along Ukraine's border, reflecting a tiered readiness force with varying levels of staffing and readiness.
Initial Invasion (February-March 2022):
Russia's initial objectives included establishing air superiority, degrading Ukrainian defenses, and swift capture of Kyiv.
The plan relied on faulty assumptions of weak Ukrainian resistance and a limited Western response.
Failure to achieve air superiority, coupled with logistical issues and fierce Ukrainian resistance, forced Russia to abandon its initial objectives.
Shift to the Donbas (April-September 2022):
After failing to capture Kyiv, Russia concentrated its efforts on eastern Ukraine, aiming to capture the Donbas region.
The sinking of Russia's Black Sea Fleet flagship, the Moskva, dealt a significant blow to Russian morale and operational capabilities.
Ukraine effectively utilized Western-supplied weapons, particularly HIMARS, to disrupt Russian logistics and counterattack in the Kharkiv region.
Partial Mobilization and Annexation (October 2022-March 2023):
Russia announced a partial mobilization, aiming to address manpower shortages and bolster its forces.
Despite its illegality, Russia annexed four Ukrainian regions (Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson, and Zaporizhzhia).
Continued Ukrainian resistance and Western support led to a stalemate on the battlefield.
Renewed Russian Offensives (April 2023-Spring 2023):
Russia launched a series of offensives, focused on capturing Bakhmut, with heavy reliance on the Wagner Group PMC.
The Wagner Group's capture of Bakhmut came at a high cost in casualties, highlighting the brutality of attritional warfare.
Ukraine received pledges of Western tanks and advanced weaponry in preparation for its own counteroffensive.
Ukraine's Counteroffensive (June 2023-Present):
Ukraine launched its highly anticipated counteroffensive in June, aiming to liberate occupied territories in the south.
The offensive has faced fierce resistance from well-prepared Russian defenses, characterized by extensive minefields.
While Ukraine has made incremental gains, the pace of progress has been slower than initially anticipated.
Russia's Defense Industrial Base:
Russia's defense industry is struggling to replenish its depleted stocks of equipment and ammunition.
Sanctions and export controls have limited Russia's access to critical components for advanced weaponry.
Russia has resorted to sanctions evasion, stockpiling, import substitution, and utilizing civilian industries to mitigate these challenges.
Outlook and Issues for Congress:
The trajectory of the war remains uncertain, with both sides demonstrating resilience and adaptive capabilities.
The long-term sustainability of Western military and financial support for Ukraine is a key consideration.
Potential implications of a protracted conflict, including spillover effects on global security and the economy, need to be assessed.
Quotes:
On Russia's initial miscalculations: "Putin was confident that he had modernized his military and they were capable of a quick, decisive victory at minimal cost. He’s been proven wrong on every count.” - CIA Director William J. Burns, March 2022.
On the importance of Western artillery support: "Since the first arrivals of M777 howitzers in April, the UAF increasingly relied on Western artillery and ammunition as its stockpiles of ammunition for its Soviet and Russian era artillery dwindled to critically low levels. The provision of Western artillery systems, and its precision targeting capability, proved decisive in the UAF’s ability to support offensive operations."
On the impact of Russia's mobilization: "Russian mobilization has worked. It is not true that their problems are so dire that these people will not fight. They will.” - General Valery Zaluzhny, Commander of Ukraine's Armed Forces, December 2022.
On the challenges of the counteroffensive: "Right now, [the Ukrainians] are preserving their combat power and they are slowly and deliberately and steadily working their way through all these minefields … It is far from a failure. I think that this is going to be long. It’s going to be hard. It’s going to be bloody.” - Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Mark Milley, July 2023.
Note: This briefing document provides an overview of the key themes and facts presented in the source document. It does not represent an exhaustive analysis of the conflict.
Timeline of Events in the Russo-Ukrainian War (Based on Provided Source)
2014:
February-March: Russia invades and annexes Crimea.
April: Russia supports separatists in eastern Ukraine, leading to the establishment of the Donetsk People’s Republic (DNR) and Luhansk People’s Republic (LNR).
2021:
December: Russia begins a sustained military build-up along the Ukrainian border, deploying troops and equipment in Belarus and occupied Crimea.
2022:
February 21: Russian President Vladimir Putin recognizes the independence of the DNR and LNR.
February 24: Russia launches a full-scale invasion of Ukraine, attacking from multiple fronts.
March - May:
March: Russian forces fail to capture Kyiv and other major cities in northern Ukraine, but make gains in the south, capturing Kherson and Mariupol.
April: Russia shifts its focus to eastern Ukraine, launching a major offensive in the Donbas region.
May: Russia captures the key cities of Severodonetsk and Lysychansk in the Donbas.
May - September:
June-July: Russia focuses on consolidating its control over captured territory in the east and south.
August: Ukraine launches a counteroffensive in the Kherson region, using Western-supplied long-range artillery systems, like HIMARS.
September: Ukraine launches a successful counteroffensive in the Kharkiv region, recapturing large swathes of territory.
September - March 2023:
September 30: Russia annexes the Ukrainian regions of Donetsk, Kherson, Luhansk, and Zaporizhia in a move widely condemned as illegal.
October - December: Russia launches a sustained missile and drone campaign targeting Ukrainian energy infrastructure. Russia conducts a “partial mobilization” to address manpower shortages.
November: Russia withdraws from the city of Kherson.
January - March 2023: Russia launches a series of offensives in eastern Ukraine, including a major push to capture the city of Bakhmut.
April - Fall 2023:
April - May: Russian offensives stall, culminating in the costly and strategically insignificant capture of Bakhmut.
May - June: Ukraine launches a long-anticipated counteroffensive, making limited initial gains but encountering heavy resistance.
June: The Wagner Group stages a brief mutiny, exposing internal divisions within Russia's military leadership.
July: Russia withdraws from the Black Sea Grain Initiative, escalating food security concerns globally.
August - September: Ukraine's counteroffensive grinds on with slow but steady progress in the south, particularly around Robotyne and towards Tokmak.
September: Ukraine achieves a breakthrough of the first and second lines of Russian defenses in the Zaporizhzhia region, marking significant progress in the counteroffensive.
Ongoing: Ukraine’s counteroffensive continues, with both sides struggling to sustain combat power and manage rates of attrition. Russia continues to grapple with internal divisions, sanctions pressure, and challenges to its defense industrial base. The long-term trajectory of the conflict remains uncertain.
Cast of Characters:
Ukraine:
Volodymyr Zelenskyy: President of Ukraine since 2019. He has emerged as a symbol of Ukrainian resistance against Russian aggression.
Valery Zaluzhny: General and Commander-in-Chief of the Ukrainian Armed Forces. He is credited with playing a key role in the successful defense against the Russian invasion.
Russia:
Vladimir Putin: President of Russia since 2000. He ordered the invasion of Ukraine in February 2022.
Sergei Shoigu: Russian Minister of Defense since 2012. He has been criticized for the Russian military’s performance in Ukraine.
Valery Gerasimov: General and Chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Russia. He was appointed the overall commander of Russian forces in Ukraine in January 2023.
Sergey Surovikin: General known as “General Armageddon” for his brutal tactics in Syria. He served as commander of Russian forces in Ukraine from October 2022 to January 2023.
Yevgeny Prigozhin: Founder and leader of the Wagner Group PMC. He played a prominent role in the Battle of Bakhmut and led a brief mutiny against the Russian military in June 2023.
Other Key Actors:
Joe Biden: President of the United States. He has led international efforts to support Ukraine and sanction Russia.
Jens Stoltenberg: Secretary General of NATO. He has played a central role in coordinating Western military assistance to Ukraine.
Lloyd Austin III: U.S. Secretary of Defense. He has overseen the provision of billions of dollars in military aid to Ukraine.
Mark A. Milley: General and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff of the U.S. Armed Forces. He has been a key advisor to President Biden on the conflict.
This timeline and cast of characters list is based solely on the information provided in the source. The information included is intended to provide a basic understanding of the main events and key figures involved in the Russo-Ukrainian War as covered in the document.
FAQ: Russia's War in Ukraine: Military and Intelligence Aspects
1. What were the key factors and assumptions that shaped Russia's initial invasion strategy in Ukraine?
Russia's initial invasion strategy was predicated on the flawed assumption that it could achieve a swift and decisive victory against Ukraine. This belief stemmed from several factors, including an overestimation of the Russian military's capabilities and modernization, underestimation of Ukrainian resistance, and a possible willingness among Russian subordinates to provide only positive information to Putin, shielding him from the true realities on the ground. These miscalculations led to a multi-pronged offensive that stretched Russian forces thin and failed to account for the determined defense mounted by Ukraine.
2. How did the initial phase of the invasion unfold, and what were the key turning points that led to the failure of Russia's initial objectives?
The invasion commenced with a focus on establishing air superiority and crippling Ukrainian defenses. However, Russia's air campaign was less effective than anticipated, allowing Ukraine to maintain a degree of control over its airspace and command-and-control capabilities. Russia's ground offensives, marked by multiple lines of advance rather than a concentrated effort, were met with fierce Ukrainian resistance. The failure to secure key objectives like the Antonov Airport near Kyiv and the mounting logistical challenges exposed vulnerabilities in Russia's military planning and execution, ultimately hindering its ability to achieve its initial goals.
3. How did Russia adapt its military strategy and tactics following the setbacks in the initial phase of the war?
Russia adjusted its approach by concentrating forces in the Donbas region, leveraging its superior artillery firepower and seeking to exploit the terrain more favorable to its operations. Despite these adaptations, Russia continued to face challenges, including personnel shortages, logistical constraints, and mounting casualties. The reliance on mercenaries like the Wagner Group and the mobilization of reservists highlighted the strain on Russia's military resources.
4. What role did Western military aid play in bolstering Ukraine's defense and enabling its counteroffensives?
Western military aid, including advanced weapons systems like HIMARS, Javelin anti-tank missiles, and Stinger anti-aircraft missiles, proved instrumental in bolstering Ukraine's defense. The provision of these systems, along with training and intelligence support, enabled Ukraine to target Russian logistics, command centers, and armored units with greater precision and effectiveness. The influx of Western weaponry played a crucial role in shifting the momentum on the battlefield and facilitating Ukraine's counteroffensive operations.
5. What were the key objectives and outcomes of Ukraine's counteroffensives in 2022 and 2023?
Ukraine's counteroffensives aimed to reclaim territory seized by Russia and demonstrate its resilience. The Kharkiv offensive in September 2022 resulted in significant territorial gains for Ukraine, liberating key cities and towns. While the 2023 counteroffensive has been more challenging due to fortified Russian defenses and extensive minefields, Ukraine has made gradual advances, focusing on attritional warfare and targeting Russian logistics and supply lines.
6. What have been the impacts of the war on Russia's defense industrial base and its ability to sustain its military operations?
The war has imposed a significant strain on Russia's defense industrial base. The high rate of equipment losses and ammunition expenditure has exposed limitations in Russia's production capacity and its reliance on foreign components. Sanctions and export controls have further hindered Russia's ability to replenish its stockpiles of advanced weaponry. Despite efforts to mobilize its industry and seek alternative suppliers, Russia faces ongoing challenges in sustaining its military operations in the long term.
7. How has the conflict affected Russia's military command structure and its relationship with mercenary groups like the Wagner Group?
The war has revealed vulnerabilities in Russia's military command structure, marked by a lack of coordination, communication breakdowns, and a disconnect between battlefield realities and political expectations. The reliance on mercenary groups like the Wagner Group highlighted both the need to supplement Russia's regular forces and the potential for internal tensions and challenges to the chain of command, culminating in the Wagner Group's mutiny in June 2023.
8. What are some of the key factors that will likely shape the future trajectory of the war?
Several factors will influence the conflict's trajectory, including the sustainability of Western military aid to Ukraine, Russia's ability to overcome its logistical and manpower challenges, and the potential for internal political pressures within Russia. The success of Ukraine's counteroffensive operations and the resilience of Russian defenses will also play a critical role in shaping the course of the war. The conflict's outcome remains uncertain, but its consequences will have lasting implications for regional security and the global geopolitical landscape.
Comments